How to Choose the Right Medical Schools to Apply To

Most premeds approach their school list the wrong way.

They Google "best medical schools," copy the US News rankings, and apply to the same 20 programs everyone else applies to — regardless of whether those schools are actually a good fit for them.

The result? Thousands of dollars in application fees, months of secondary essays, and a pile of rejections that could have been avoided with a smarter strategy.

Choosing the right schools is one of the most important — and most underestimated — parts of the medical school application process. Done well, it dramatically improves your odds. Done poorly, it can sink an otherwise strong application.

Here is how to do it right.

---

Start With Your Numbers — But Don't Stop There

Your GPA and MCAT score are the first filter. Every school publishes median stats for their accepted students, and you need to know where you stand relative to those numbers.

A general framework:

• Reach schools: Your GPA or MCAT is below the school's median (apply to 3–5)
• Target schools: Your stats are at or near the median (apply to 8–12)
• Safety schools: Your stats are comfortably above the median (apply to 3–5)

This gives you a balanced list of 15–20 schools — enough to maximize your chances without spreading yourself so thin that your secondary essays become generic.

Important: MSAR (the AAMC's Medical School Admissions Requirements database) is your best friend here. It gives you the 10th–90th percentile GPA and MCAT ranges for every MD program in the country. Use it.

But here is the mistake most students make: they treat their numbers as the only variable. They are not.

---

Understand Mission Fit — It Matters More Than You Think

Every medical school has a mission. Some prioritize primary care. Others focus on research. Some are deeply committed to serving underserved communities. Others emphasize rural medicine, global health, or a specific patient population.

Admissions committees read thousands of applications. They are not just looking for students with high scores — they are looking for students who genuinely align with what their school is trying to do.

Ask yourself:

• Does this school emphasize research? Do I have research experience and genuine interest in it?
• Is this a primary care-focused school? Does my application reflect a commitment to primary care?
• Does this school serve a specific community? Can I speak authentically to that mission?

If you cannot answer "yes" to at least one of these questions, that school may not be the right fit — no matter what your numbers say.

Mission fit is not just about getting in. It is about finding a school where you will thrive, where the curriculum matches how you learn, and where the culture supports the kind of physician you want to become.

---

Consider Location More Seriously Than Most Students Do

Location affects your application more than most premeds realize — for two reasons.

First, in-state preference is real. Many state schools give significant preference to in-state applicants. If you are a New York resident, SUNY schools should be near the top of your target list. The acceptance rates for in-state applicants at public schools are often two to three times higher than for out-of-state applicants.

Second, schools often prefer students with ties to their region. A school in rural Appalachia wants to know that you understand and are committed to that community. A school in a major urban center wants to see that you have experience in diverse, high-volume clinical environments.

If you have no connection to a region and no compelling reason to be there, that school may deprioritize your application — even if your numbers are strong.

---

Research the Curriculum and Learning Style

This is the step most applicants skip entirely — and it shows in their secondary essays.

Medical schools vary significantly in how they teach:

• Traditional (lecture-based) vs. problem-based learning (PBL)
• Early clinical exposure vs. two years of pre-clinical before seeing patients
• Pass/fail grading vs. traditional letter grades
• Integrated curriculum vs. organ-system-based blocks

None of these is objectively better. But one of them is probably better for you — based on how you learn, what motivates you, and what kind of physician you want to become.

When you can speak specifically to a school's curriculum in your secondary essays, it signals genuine interest. Admissions committees notice.

---

Do Not Ignore Smaller or Less-Recognized Schools

There is a persistent myth in the premed world that only going to a top-20 medical school leads to a good career. This is simply not true.

Residency programs care about your Step scores, your clinical performance, your letters of recommendation, and your fit for their program. They care far less about the name on your medical school diploma than premeds believe.

Some of the best-prepared physicians I have worked with trained at schools you have never heard of. Some of the most struggling residents I have seen came from highly ranked programs.

A school that is a genuine fit — where you will be supported, challenged, and prepared — is worth more than a prestigious name that leaves you struggling to keep up.

---

Build Your List Collaboratively

Here is the honest truth: most premeds are not well-positioned to evaluate their own applications objectively. You are too close to it.

You do not know how your GPA and MCAT compare to this year's applicant pool. You do not know which schools are becoming more or less competitive. You do not know which programs have shifted their mission priorities or changed their secondary essay prompts.

A good mentor or advisor does.

Building your school list should be a collaborative process — one that combines your self-knowledge (your story, your goals, your clinical experiences) with someone else's knowledge of the landscape (current acceptance data, school-specific preferences, regional considerations).

That combination is what produces a list that is both strategic and authentic.

---

A Practical Framework for Building Your List

Here is a step-by-step approach:

1. Pull your MSAR data. Identify every school where your GPA and MCAT fall within the 10th–90th percentile range. This is your starting universe.

2. Filter by mission fit. Remove schools whose mission does not align with your story. Add schools whose mission you can speak to authentically.

3. Apply in-state preference. Move your state's public schools into the target or safety category, regardless of their overall ranking.

4. Research curricula. Spend 20 minutes on each school's website. Read their "About" page, their curriculum overview, and their mission statement. Take notes. You will use this in your secondaries.

5. Check geographic ties. If you have no connection to a region and no compelling reason to be there, deprioritize those schools.

6. Finalize your balance. Aim for 15–20 schools: 3–5 reaches, 8–12 targets, 3–5 safeties.

7. Get a second opinion. Have someone with admissions knowledge review your list before you submit.

---

The Bottom Line

Your school list is not just a list of schools you want to attend. It is a strategic document that reflects your self-awareness, your research, and your understanding of what you bring to the table.

The students who get in are not always the ones with the highest scores. They are the ones who applied to the right schools, told a coherent story, and demonstrated genuine fit. For a deeper, step-by-step breakdown of this process, read our full guide: How to Build the Perfect Medical School List.

That starts with the list.

---

Dr. Tomei is a physician, educator, and founder of MedTrack Mentors. He has helped hundreds of students build strategic school lists and craft competitive applications. If you want personalized guidance on your school list, schedule a free consultation.