Physician Shadowing
in New York State
Finding physician shadowing in New York is harder than it looks. This guide covers the most effective paths to shadowing opportunities across the state — and what to do once you're in the room.
Why Physician Shadowing Matters for NY Medical School Applicants
Physician shadowing serves a different purpose than clinical volunteering. Volunteering demonstrates that you can work in a clinical environment and engage with patients. Shadowing demonstrates that you understand what physicians actually do — the decision-making, the uncertainty, the communication, the documentation, and the weight of the role.
Admissions committees use shadowing to assess whether an applicant has a realistic picture of medicine. A student who has only read about medicine is a different candidate than one who has stood in an exam room and watched a physician deliver a difficult diagnosis. That experience — and the reflection it generates — is what shadowing is supposed to produce.
In New York, shadowing is more logistically challenging than in many other states. HIPAA compliance requirements, hospital credentialing processes, and post-pandemic access restrictions have made it harder to get into clinical settings as a non-employee observer. The strategies below are the most reliable paths given the current environment.
Dr. Tomei's Perspective
Important: Physician shadowing access, institutional policies, and program availability change frequently. This page describes strategies and potential sources of shadowing opportunities — it does not confirm that any specific institution currently operates a formal shadowing program. Confirm current policies and availability directly with each organization before planning your schedule.
Finding Opportunities
Six Paths to Physician Shadowing in New York
Your pre-health advising office
Most NY universities with pre-med programs maintain a list of physicians who have agreed to host student shadowers. This is the lowest-friction starting point — the relationship is already established and the physician expects to hear from students.
Hospital volunteer programs as a pipeline
Many NY pre-med students find shadowing opportunities through physicians they meet during hospital volunteer shifts. A physician who has seen you work with patients is far more likely to say yes to a shadowing request than a cold contact.
Family medicine and primary care physicians
Primary care physicians — family medicine, internal medicine, pediatrics — are generally more accessible to shadowers than specialists. They also provide the broadest exposure to the patient-physician relationship, which is what admissions committees most want to see.
Cold outreach to physicians in your specialty of interest
If you have a specific specialty in mind, direct outreach to physicians in that field is appropriate. A brief, professional email explaining your background, your interest in the specialty, and your request for a limited number of shadowing hours has a reasonable response rate. Keep it short — one paragraph.
Academic medical center programs
Some NY academic medical centers have offered formal shadowing or observership programs for pre-med students at various times. Check each institution's website directly for current availability — NYU Langone, NewYork-Presbyterian, and Northwell Health are worth contacting, but program availability is not guaranteed and changes frequently.
Physicians in your personal network
Family friends, neighbors, and community members who are physicians are a legitimate and often underutilized resource. There is nothing improper about asking a physician you know personally for a shadowing opportunity — they understand the application process and are often glad to help.
By Specialty
Shadowing Access by Specialty in New York
Note: Access restrictions vary significantly by institution and change over time. Always verify current policies directly with the hospital or practice before planning your schedule.
Primary Care (Family Medicine, Internal Medicine, Pediatrics)
Highest accessibility for shadowers. Broadest exposure to the patient-physician relationship. Strongly recommended as a baseline for all applicants regardless of intended specialty.
Surgery
Operating room access for non-medical personnel is heavily restricted in NY hospitals post-COVID. Outpatient surgical clinics and pre-op/post-op settings are more accessible. Expect limited OR time.
Emergency Medicine
ED shadowing is highly variable by institution. Some NY EDs have formal programs; others prohibit non-staff observers entirely. Verify before pursuing.
Psychiatry
Patient privacy concerns make psychiatry shadowing more restricted than other specialties. Some outpatient practices accommodate shadowers; inpatient settings are generally closed.
Specialty Clinics (Cardiology, Oncology, Neurology, etc.)
Outpatient specialty clinics are often more accessible than inpatient settings. Academic medical center clinics affiliated with NY medical schools sometimes have formal programs.
Conduct
What to Do (and Not Do) During Shadowing
Do
Arrive early, dress professionally, and introduce yourself to every member of the care team.
Observe actively — take mental notes on how the physician communicates with patients, handles uncertainty, and makes decisions.
Ask thoughtful questions at appropriate moments — between patients, not during a patient encounter.
Send a thank-you note within 24 hours of each shadowing session.
Keep a detailed log: date, physician name, specialty, setting, hours, and specific observations you want to reference in your application.
Don't
Do not use your phone during patient encounters — ever.
Do not ask the physician to write you a letter of recommendation on your first day. Build the relationship first.
Do not shadow only one physician in one specialty — admissions committees want to see breadth.
Do not treat shadowing as passive observation. Engage, ask questions, and demonstrate genuine curiosity.